Give Now  »

Noon Edition

Cloudy vs clear apple juice: Which do you prefer?

Read Transcript
Hide Transcript

Transcript

Y: What kind of apple juice do you like better, Don, clear or cloudy?

D: Hmm, I guess clear, Yael. It looks better than the cloudy stuff, for one thing.

Y: True, I hear you. But you do know that cloudy apple juice is better for you?

D: Really? How so?

Y: Well, according to a study done in Poland, cloudy apple juice has more antioxidants than the clear stuff.

D: You mean the chemicals that help control free radical molecules that can damage cells and cause disease?

Y: Yep. See, when apple juice is made, to get clear juice you use an enzyme that basically takes out a lot of the juice's natural antioxidants.

D: And I'm guessing that cloudy juice doesn't use this enzyme, so it packs a better antioxidant punch.

Y: Right. What makes cloudy apple juice cloudy is the presence of apple solids--not actual chunks of apple, of course, but small particles that are strained out in clear juice. It's the solids that contain the antioxidants.

D: Okay, so maybe I'll switch to cloudy apple juice from now on.

Y: Or, you could eat more actual apples with the skin. To really get the full benefit of an apple's antioxidants and other healthy components like fiber and minerals, eating real apples, and not just drinking their juice, is the way to go.

A variety of apple juice from the Martinelli brand, some unfiltered and cloudy while others are clear

According to a study done in Poland, cloudy apple juice has more antioxidants than the clear stuff. (Marco Verch / flickr)

What kind of apple juice do you like better, clear or cloudy? Most people prefer clear, since it looks better than the cloudy stuff, for one thing.

That's understandable. But do you know that cloudy apple juice is better for you?

According to a study done in Poland, cloudy apple juice has more antioxidants than the clear stuff. These are the chemicals that help control free radical molecules that can damage cells and cause disease. 

When apple juice is made, to get clear juice you use an enzyme that basically takes out a lot of the juice's natural antioxidants. Cloudy apple juice doesn't use that enzyme, so it packs a better antioxidant punch.

What makes cloudy apple juice cloudy is the presence of apple solids--not actual chunks of apple, of course, but small particles that are strained out in clear juice. It's the solids that contain the antioxidants.

So if you want the benefits of apple juice, you could switch to cloudy. Or, you could eat more actual apples with the skin. To really get the full benefit of an apple's antioxidants and other healthy components like fiber and minerals, eating real apples, and not just drinking their juice, is the way to go.

Read more

Sources

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

About A Moment of Science