Owen County Commissioners President Jeff Brothers looks on as county attorney Jim Bryan reads the commissioners' revised festival ordinance at their Dec. 16 meeting
(Mitch Legan, WTIU/WFIU News)
The Owen County Commissioners introduced and adopted their revised festival ordinance at Monday night’s meeting in Spencer.
This came less than 12 hours after the Commissioners made the edited ordinance available to the public on Monday morning.
The new ordinance, which is now law, is essentially the original proposal – just with cleaner language that makes it less likely to be subject to litigation.
Over 30 people attended Monday night's meeting in what many thought would be the first reading of a revised festival ordinance that has been the cause of immense controversy in the county since August.
But after Owen County attorney Jim Bryan read the revised ordinance aloud for the first time, Commissioners President Jeff Brothers moved to vote on the issue without allowing the public to comment.
“You’re not going to allow for public comment?” resident Katelyn Keith asked, exasperated. “This is something that hundreds, if not thousands of people have spoken on over the last five or six months. And you’re not going to allow anyone to say anything? About something you just introduced this morning?”
Commissioner Gary Burton shook his head no as Brothers explained that the Commissioners’ obligation to listen to the public had already been fulfilled when they held a public comment session on the original draft over a month ago.
“Jeff, this is irresponsible behavior,” resident Ronan Young said. “You’re not letting the people give input. You put this out to the people this morning. You’ve made some fantastic improvements, but it’s not where it needs to be to keep the people happy. You could be the good guys in this, instead of everybody thinking we’re a county full of jerks.”
“You’re taking us backwards,” he continued. “Listen to the people; listen to their input. Get everybody’s input and do something about it.”
“We represent 22,000 people,” Brothers contested.
“And you’re not going to let any of them speak,” Young responded.
As the back-and-forth between the Commissioners and public turned to shouting yet again, Brothers asked County Sherriff Sam Hobbs to clear the Owen County Courthouse “if we [the Commissioners] don’t get the respect that we’re required.”
Hobbs said he told Brothers he had to let the public know beforehand if he was not going to allow for public comment. The Commissioners made no such announcement.
The new ordinance addresses some concerns residents raised during the aforementioned public comment meeting on Nov. 4.
The new ordinance no longer gives the Commissioners say over any event anywhere in the county; it now says the Commissioners can only make decisions on special events that happen on the courthouse square. It also cleans up the language concerning fees and makes them more reasonable for a county like Owen.
“It [the courthouse] is a public house – why can’t it still be used for that?” Young asked. “I think that you guys rushed this ordinance through, thinking you were going to get it through without pushback from the people. People started to push back, and you still just pushed and rushed it through without stopping. You create commissions for everything to get public input, but you wouldn’t do it on this one.”
The Commissioners also kept a section that now prohibits “sexually explicit materials” and nudity, something Spencer Pride President Jonathan Balash has said is an obvious nod to the Spencer Pride Fest.
Now that the Commissioners approved the ordinance, Balash says the Spencer Pride Fest will not be on the courthouse lawn for the first time in over a decade.
“We already have a fantastic plan to make a larger event than we’ve ever had,” Balash says. “An event that’s more engaging with our downtown organizations and businesses, an event that’s gonna be bigger and bolder than it’s ever been.”