Give Now  »

wfiu logo
WFIU Public Radio

wtiu logo
WTIU Public Television

Choose which station to support!

Indiana Public Media | WFIU - NPR | WTIU - PBS

How Much Does It Cost To Eat Healthy?

Two side-by-side photos.  On the left, two carrots that grew wrapped around one another, as though they are hugging.  On the right, close-up of a hand holding a packaged twinkie.

A new USDA study challenges the notion that eating healthy food is invariably more expensive than eating junk.

According to Andrea Carlson, lead author for the study, the key is which units researchers decide to employ in their calculations.

Price Per Calorie, Price Per Gram, Price Per Average Portion

In the past, determining the cost-effectiveness of a given food item has involved dividing its price by the amount of calories it contains. If a Snickers bar costs a dollar, for example, then each of its 250 calories is worth less than half a cent.

As it turns out, when considered in terms of price per calorie, junk food is almost always more economical than more wholesome options.

In the most recent study, however, price per gram and the price per portion replaced price per calorie. Under this mathematical regime, healthy foods often compare favorably to unhealthy alternatives

How Does It Work?Â

Three o'clock rolls around and it's time for your afternoon snack. You have two choices: a Twinkie or a carrot.

A single Twinkie gives you 150 calories and, let's be honest, if you've got a box handy, you're probably going to go back for seconds.

A large carrot, on the other hand, is only 72 calories, but you'll probably feel full enough to stop eating after just one.

If the Twinkies and the carrot cost the same, then the Twinkies have given you far more calories for your money. Per portion and per gram, however, the carrot comes out cheaper.

Eat This, Not That

To qualify as "healthy," foods had to contain ingredients from at least one of the USDA-recognized food groups (fruits, vegetables, grains, proteins, dairy) and contain limited amounts of sodium, added sugar and saturated fat.

Unhealthy foods, on the other hand, were those that contained little or nothing from any of the food groups and/or were high in sodium, sugar and/or saturated fat.

A number of healthy foods like lentils, beans, carrots, onions and mashed potatoes consistently ranked cheaper than ice cream, sweet rolls, pork chops, or ground beef when price was calculated by portion and weight.

Read More:

  • How To Make Healthier Eating Easier On The Wallet? Change The Calculation (NPR)
  • USDA: Healthy Food Isn't Really More Expensive (CNN)
  • Healthy Foods Not Necessarily More Expensive Than Unhealthy Ones (USDA)

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

About Earth Eats

Harvest Public Media