Give Now

Earth Eats: Real Food, Green Living

In Bowman V. Monsanto, Bad Prospects For Bowman

Indiana Farmer Vernon Bowman faced a cold reception in the Supreme Court on Tuesday.

Brass judge's gavel.

Photo: walknboston (Flickr)

The Supreme Court is expected to issue a final ruling on the Bowman v. Monsanto case in June.

David And Goliath

Agribusiness giant Monsanto has taken Indiana farmer Vernon Hugh Bowman to the highest court of the land. The issue: Bowman’s long-time practice of planting patented soybean seeds without paying the company a fee.

Judging by the initial reactions of all nine Supreme Court justices, it looks like David probably isn’t going to win the battle against Goliath this time around.

A New Kind Of Seed Is Born

During the ’80s and ’90s, Monsanto invested hundreds of millions of dollars to develop, patent and market seeds genetically modified to survive regular applications of the company’s popular herbicide, Roundup.

While the seeds’ hardiness makes pest control a lot easier, the catch is that planters must sign a contract that says they will not save and reuse seeds year-to-year.

Instead, farmers enter into a legally-binding agreement that they will buy new seeds directly from Monsanto at the beginning of each planting season.

Grain Silo Loophole

Having purchased and employed Roundup Ready seeds legitimately in past years, Bowman had signed Monsanto’s contract.

In 1999, however, he decided to purchased a stock of cheap grain from a nearby silo. Due to the grain’s intended use as feed, it wasn’t advertised as containing Roundup Ready seeds.

But Bowman knew the grain very likely harbored a fair amount of custom-built Monsanto genes, and so he devised a plan to separate the resistant strains from the non-resistant ones.

The strategy was simple. Follow his normal routine of sowing seed and applying a steady stream of Roundup. The plants with Roundup Ready DNA would be easily identified as those that didn’t succumb to the herbicide, and their seeds would be collected and saved for the following year. In other words, Bowman would use natural selection to do the sorting for him.

And for eight years, that’s just what he did — until Monsanto sued in 2007.

Patent Exhaustion

Bowman’s lawyers argued that since the seed Bowman cultivated was the offspring of Monsanto grain and not Monsanto grain itself, the doctrine of “patent exhaustion” should prevent him from being penalized for his actions.

But the Indiana Federal Court and, later, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit disagreed, ruling that Bowman’s actions did amount to patent infringement and that he owed Monsanto over $84,000.

The case is now being deliberated in the Supreme Court.

Bowman Victory Appears Unlikely

On the first day of hearings, justices seemed generally unsympathetic to Bowman’s claim.

“Why in the world would anybody spend any money to try to improve the seed if as soon as they sold the first one, anybody could grow more and have as many of those seeds as they want?” said Chief Justice John Roberts.

Even the more liberal justices seemed to side with Monsanto.

“The exhaustion doctrine permits you to use the good that you buy,” said Justice Sonia Sotomayor. “It never permits you to make another item from that item you bought.”

Read More:

Sarah Gordon

Sarah Gordon has been interested in food ethics since she was 15, learned about industrial slaughter, and launched into 10 years of vegetarianism. These days, she strives to be a conscientious omnivore. Now a PhD candidate in folklore, her research has caused her to spend a lot of time in the remote Canadian sub-arctic, where the lake trout (sustainably harvested) tastes amazing.

View all posts by this author »

  • http://www.facebook.com/ken.jones.35728 Ken Jones

    Patents only last twenty years, some of Monsanto’s have already expired. These could well inspire a whole generation of backyard GM inventors trying out ideas in their own fields and patenting themselves without attorneys, by simply rewriting Monsanto expired patents and adding in their own modifications. This can even even be done right now. These days you can do the whole patent process online, internationally. Even applying for a US Provisional patent is not the cheapest way to go, apply for a UK patent and you get a year to pay any fees and your UK Filing Date is good for your Non-Provisional US Patent. If nobody is interested in a year, just abandon your patent and it has cost you nothing. If someone is interested the royalty advance can pay the fees. A great cheap Amazon ebook which explains all this is DIY Patent Online, it includes links to search and filing sites and lists all the fees, plus you can even read some of it free. They also have a website but aren’t trying to sell their services like most patent sites. Attorney’s must love them. Populations need to be fed and until World population begins to contract, Monsanto is in business. However like all products Monsanto will hit a maturity barrier and that is when new backyard GM seed inventors, working in a similar way to Vernon Bowman and doing the patents themselves, could be in for a field day. Literally.

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Earth Eats:

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

About Earth Eats

Search Earth Eats

Earth Eats on Twitter

Earth Eats on Flickr

Harvest Public Media