The head of the Jesus sculpture, which has stood outside Cottage Avenue Pentecostal Fellowship for four years, has been removed twice this month.
Police are seeking tips from the public in the investigation.
Officials in Kokomo are condemning racist graffiti that was found spray-painted on yard signs for Democratic Party candidates.
The bullet holes aren't the first report of vandalism at ISNA. Three men painted racial slurs on the building in February.
Someone sprayed black paint on Indiana University's Sample Gates and other nearby properties early Saturday morning.
Reports issued to the Bloomington Police Department had some in the Jewish community worried about hate crimes on IU's campus.
For some, the possibility of getting caught is part of the thrill and one of the main reasons graffiti artists keep to the streets.
The garage is now handicap accessible 24 hours a day.
Mark Zacharias made his first court appearance today, but his pre-trial conference was rescheduled to April.
The Indiana University employee who is being charged with committing an act of anti-Semitic vandalism has been fired.