Give Now

A Moment of Science

Why Our Brains’ Sniff Imaginary Roses

When we imagine a rose, why do we sniff out loud to smell it?


Photo: spisharam - AWAY (flickr)

You're well aware there's no rose by your why do you inhale?

When you imagine smelling a rose, do you take a sniff or not?

Think about it for a second. Since the imagined rose only exists in your brain, you don’t need to sniff the real world at all. You’re well aware there’s no rose by your nose. Nevertheless, a study by Moustafa Bensafi at the University of California, Berkeley, showed that we do indeed sniff when we are imagining the smell of something.

To Sniff Or Not To Sniff?

Better than that, Bensafi and his team found that volunteers sniffed more deeply when imagining a pleasant sensation, such as a rose, than when imaging an unpleasant sensation, such as rotten eggs. This was determined by using a machine that measured nasal airflow. The volunteers knew there were no rotten eggs in the room, but they still didn’t want to inhale too deeply!

What is this showing us about how our brains work?

Previous studies have shown that people move their eyes when imagining an object, and even have trouble visualizing something if they can’t move their eyes. Added to such studies, the sniffing evidence suggests that our sense-organs and our mental representations are hard-wired.

That is, sniffing isn’t one thing and activating olfactory receptors another and generating a mental rose a third; they are all part of a single process. Evidently this process can be activated in reverse order when we generate a mental rose–or rotten egg–and cause our sniffers to take an automatic whiff.

Stay Connected

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from A Moment of Science:

Support for Indiana Public Media Comes From

About A Moment of Science

Search A Moment of Science