Education, From The Capitol To The Classroom

Endorsing Glenda Ritz, Journal Gazette Offers Critique Of Tony Bennett's Policies

Photos courtesy of the Bennett and Ritz campaigns

Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Bennett, left, is running for reelection against Democrat Glenda Ritz.

If the state superintendent’s race will be decided on a question of whether incumbent Tony Bennett‘s education policies push too far too fast, here’s how the editorial board of the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette answered in its endorsement of his challenger, Glenda Ritz:

Indiana enjoyed almost 24 years of steady, collaborative effort to improve public education under Republicans H. Dean Evans and Suellen Reed, but Bennett’s election four years ago marked an end to the partnership among policymakers, educators, parents and the business community. The noteworthy improvement Indiana schools have made in recent years, including higher graduation rates, is the result of the foundation Evans and Reed set.

Rather than follow their example, Bennett cleaned house, replacing experienced educators with a DOE staff whose frequent turnover has left school districts struggling to interpret rules and requirements. He took advantage of GOP majorities to push an expansive legislative agenda, including the nation’s most expansive voucher program. Before its effects are even known, he is looking to extend it, eliminating the restriction that vouchers go only to students who first attend public school.

The newspaper also takes Bennett to task for putting more state dollars in the hands of for-profit charter school operators and pushing for legislation that makes it easier to get a teaching license in Indiana.

Ritz, a teacher in Indianapolis’ Washington Township, gets the Journal Gazette‘s endorsement for her 32 years of experience and plan to rework the Indiana Department of Education from the “bottom up.” But she still faces an uphill battle when it comes to fundraising.

The release of the latest campaign finance reports is still a few weeks away, but it looks like Bennett will have brought in more than a million dollars. By contrast, Ritz has about $100,000 to make her final push. We’ve written about the number of large contributions that have come in for Bennett from out-of-state, which the Journal Gazette calls “troubling.” The newspaper notes Bennett’s predecessor, longtime state superintendent Suellen Reed, ran her final campaign in 2004 with about $39,000.

But Bennett has defended his aggressive push to transform Indiana schools, telling StateImpact he’d prefer to advocate for change now rather than wait for students to fail. He also adds that Ritz has had the same opportunities to court out-of-state donors and he won’t apologize for running a political race:

We have very strong Republicans. We have very strong Democrats. We have the most prominent independent in the United States in (New York Mayor) Michael Bloomberg. So we haven’t just raised money along party lines. We’ve raised money really through individuals who have a strong belief that education reform in Indiana is a model for the country and they want us to succeed. I am honored that they feel that way. I frankly don’t apologize for the level of fundraising we’ve done in state and out of state because it would also be misplaced to not recognize that we have a large proportion of our dollars from in state as well. We have attracted a very loyal donor base based on the fact that people believe Indiana education is heading in the right direction.

Ritz has said she won’t accept large out-of-state contributions and is relying on grassroots support from local teachers unions to run her race. Her biggest supporter is the Indiana State Teachers Association.


  • Bilgewater

    I haven’t seen any Bennett signs out. The repbulican backers have Romney, Pence, Walorski, and Mourdock signs in their yards. The election is not far off…so what’s he doing with his money? I can photocopy Ritz signs and put them on a stick and put to the lie that Bennett’s money will get him more recognition. I say vote for Ritz and send Bennett (nd his money) packing.

    Bennett is not resposible to Indiana voters or Indiana laws. He is beholden to big men behind big desks in Washington, New York, and Indianapolis. He does not answer to the legislature, the voters, schoolteachers, or children.

  • RetiringSoon

    I am a teacher in NE Indiana at a very small public school with a very high graduation rate. As ridiculous as the present school rating system is (and as badly as Dr. Bennett would like to see small schools consolidate), we did have an “A” rating last year. My school offers more dual credit classes then most schools twice our size and larger. We regularly have students who are recognized at the state level, not only for sports achievements, but for academics. We do what we do for students to prepare them for college and careers with a small dedicated staff, despite the fact that we have not had an increase in our pay for two years. With no signs of any increased funding coming our way, I doubt we will see any “rasises” this year either. This is all despite the fabulous new evaluation process (affectionately called RISE) that requires teachers to spend so much time documenting what we have done, are doing, will do to make sure that our students are excelling in our classrooms, that we no longer have time to spend updating our lessons so that our students can excel further, attending sporting events to show our students that we also support them outside the classroom, or even doing things with our own families.
    NOTE: (1) I am not a member of my local association, (2) I do believe that RISE is probably not going away, and (3) I am a proponent of the Common Core, BUT the madness at the IDOE has to stop! We need to have content area state specialists who are classroom/education-experienced in their content areas, we need to know that our profession is valued enough that it reqires a content-area, education-degreed person to replace us, and we need to see our valued tax dollars coming back to the public schools . . .ONLY!!
    Please, please, PLEASE DO NOT VOTE for Tony Bennett on November, 6th!

About StateImpact

StateImpact seeks to inform and engage local communities with broadcast and online news focused on how state government decisions affect your lives.
Learn More »