Protesters Meet Loggers at Yellowwood Forest Timber Sale

Citizens opposed to logging on public land are hoping to educate people on what they say is happening to the state’s forests.

Tree in Morgan Monroe

Photo: Bill Shaw

Logging in state forests has increased since Governor Mitch Daniels took office and protesters are trying to raise awareness.

Citizens opposed to logging on public land are hoping to educate people on what they say is happening to the state’s forests.  Protesters gathered at Yellowwood State Forest Thursday during a timber auction.  They said they knew they wouldn’t be able to stop the sale, but they wanted to encourage people to get involved to change the state’s policies on commercial logging.  The group, Indiana Forest Alliance is opposed to the increase in logging since Governor Mitch Daniels took office and the rise in clear cut logging.  That process involves removing all the trees on a selected tract of land.  Indiana Forest Alliance President Dan Haberman says one of the tracts sold at the sale involved a 16 acre clear cut opening.

“Clear cut openings have been shown to be very damaging for soil, for water production in the forests, and certainly has been very harmful for biodiversity.”  Haberman said.  “There are birds, songbirds, who nest in our forests who completely depend on mature forests with a closed canopy.”

The sale was predominately pine trees.  Haberman says the DNR claims if the trees weren’t harvested they’d be wasted.  But Haberman says a significant number of nutrients will be removed when the trees are taken out and that will harm the forest.

Dan Ernst is the Assistant State Forester with the Division of Forestry.  He says the tracts being auctioned were last harvested 25 years ago under a selective harvesting system.  He says he’s comfortable with the department’s logging procedures.

“You know everybody has their own opinion and there are those who would like to see no cutting in the state forests.”  Ernst said. “Then there are those who appreciate that the state forest system is managed in a sustainable manner. In fact we’re licensed under the forest stewardship council and the sustainable forest initiative.”

But according to the Indiana Forest Alliance, most Hoosiers aren’t aware logging occurs on public land and polls taken when Governor Mitch Daniels took office show the majority of people do not want commercial logging in state forests.

Haberman says since Daniels took office logging in state forests has increased 500%.  Ernst says the reason that increase seems so dramatic is because harvesting in Indiana has traditionally been light.  He says the state still currently cuts 50% or less of the annual growth.  The tracts sold at the  auction together went for about $67,000.

Sara Wittmeyer

Sara Wittmeyer is the News Bureau Chief for WFIU and WTIU. Sara has more than a decade of experience as a news reporter and previously served with KBIA at the University of Missouri, WNKU at Northern Kentucky University in Highland Heights, KY, and at WCPO News in Cincinnati.

View all posts by this author »

  • TYG

    I would like to see the references Haberman is using for his information. A clear cut (if it is a true clear cut where all trees are removed and not a commercial clear cut where only the large trees are removed) is designed to mimic a fire or other natural disaster. While nutrients will be removed and the soil will be exposed to more erosion these affects are relatively short lived. The majority of the nutrients in a tree are in the leaves and branches which are often left behind after a harvest. Indiana's state forests are cut on rotation to increase state revenue (thereby reducing taxes), improve carbon sequestration, and provide wood and paper for our use. Yes, rotational harvesting is not the same as no harvesting and there are species that are directly affected. But, the state and national forests were set up to protect the ability of the United States to provide forest products for itself and reduce destructive harvesting practices that would take away that ability. Private landowners do not have the ability to plan for rotations of greater than 100 years as new generations often have their own objectives. If you'd like to see our forests and the benifits they provide stick around, please encourage them to be managed for the greatest good over the greatest amount of time.

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Indiana Public Media News:

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

Search News

Stay Connected

RSS e-mail itunes Facebook Twitter Flickr YouTube

Follow us on Twitter

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Indiana Public Media News:

Recent Politics Stories

Recent Videos

Find Us on Facebook