Committee Sends HJR-3 To Full Senate Without Amendments

The full Senate will likely vote on the measure this week.

HJR3 Supporters

Photo: Brandon Smith/IPBS

A group of HJR-3 supporters hold signs in favor of traditional marriage at the Indiana statehouse.

Update 7:15 p.m.:

A Senate committee today approved HJR-3, the proposed constitutional amendment banning same sex marriage.

The debate surrounding the measure shifted during Monday’s hearing, focusing more on the restoration of the amendment’s controversial second sentence:

The House removed HJR-3’s second sentence, which bans civil unions, after concerns were raised it could prohibit domestic partnership benefits.

Proponents of the measure, including Governor Mike Pence, are calling on the Senate to reinsert that language.

Doug Mainwaring, who identifies as gay, says he recently recommitted to his ex-wife after realizing the importance of traditional marriage. He says the second sentence’s ban on civil unions helps ensure traditional marriage isn’t undermined.

“The state should not incentivize relationships that intentionally deprive children of either a mom or a dad,” he says.

Jennifer Fisher, who identifies as lesbian, lives in Fort Wayne with her partner. She says if the Senate can’t reject HJR-3 outright, it at least shouldn’t reinsert the second sentence.

“Because that is the sentence that means that I have no protection with my family,” she says. “It means that my partner and I have no valid relationship in Indiana.”

Senate President Pro Tem David Long is remaining mum about whether he thinks the Senate should reinsert the controversial second sentence of HJR3, the proposed constitutional amendment banning same sex marriage.

Proponents of the measure, including Governor Mike Pence, are calling on the Senate to reinsert the second sentence. 

Long won’t say which way he’ll vote if the full Senate tries to reinsert the second sentence. But he says whether House lawmakers will support HJR-3 if returned to them in its original form won’t impact him.

“And we really have to just stick to what we think we should do here in the Senate and what a majority of the senators decide to do will be what ultimately happens,” Long says. “We can’t speculate on what the House will or won’t do and I think that’s the right approach and that’s the way we’ll try to approach it here.”

Senate Minority Leader Tim Lanane says approving HJR-3 would insert discrimination into the state constitution.

“We certainly cannot put that second clause back into this proposal.  It just causes all types of problems,” he says.

Long says he wants HJR-3 to come up on the floor for potential changes Thursday, though he says that decision will rest with his caucus.

The committee approved the measure 8-4.

It now heads to the floor, where the full Senate could consider reinserting the second sentence as early as Thursday.

Update 5:29 p.m.:

The Senate committee approves HJR-3 in its current form without the second sentence in an 8-4 vote along party lines. The measure now heads to Senate floor.

Update 4:34 p.m.:

Testimony in the Senate hearing on HJR-3 today is focusing on the same topics covered in previous testimony in the House.

That includes the economic impact the amendment would have on the state and arguments relating to religious freedom.

But pro-HJR-3 testimony additionally focused on asking Senators to restore the second sentence, which outlaws civil unions. Doing so would likely send the bill to the voters this year instead of in 2016.

Protestors both opposing and supporting HJR-3 lined up to get into the Senate gallery hours before the hearing started.

Original Story:

The legislative debate over HJR-3 restarts this week as the Senate takes up the proposed constitutional amendment banning same sex marriage.

HJR-3 arrives in the Senate very different than when it first started in the House.  Gone is the measure’s second sentence, which bans civil unions.

After concerns were raised that the second sentence could prohibit domestic partnership benefits, a bipartisan group of House lawmakers removed it, which would also restart the ratification process, potentially putting the amendment on the ballot not this fall, but in 2016.

Governor Mike Pence is calling on the Senate to reinsert the second sentence and end the debate on the issue this year.  HJR-3 will be heard in a Senate committee Monday, where it’s eligible to be changed.

But Senate President Pro Tem David Long says he wants the move the measure out of committee unchanged, leaving it open to alteration on the Senate floor.

If HJR-3 is passed out of committee Monday as Long intends, it could be eligible for changes on the floor Thursday.

This story will be updated. Jashin Lin contributed to this report.

Brandon Smith, IPBS

Brandon Smith, IPBS has previously worked as a reporter and anchor for KBIA Radio in Columbia, MO, and at WSPY Radio in Plano, IL as a show host, reporter, producer and anchor. Brandon graduated from the University of Missouri-Columbia with a Bachelor of Journalism in 2010, with minors in political science and history. He was born and raised in Chicago.

View all posts by this author »

  • greenpointguy

    The caption on the photo should say “A group from a historically discriminated-against minority show signs of support for discriminating against another minority group.” Sad.

  • JakePH

    Odd that the marriage ban crowd got the only pic here. The equality group had a FAR better turnout, and a good turnout at every step of this (I believe this was the homophobes’ first substantial appearance). And you think NOM could have at least bussed in some people with better personality. I have never seen a more uncourteous group of adults in my entire life than that congregation. Never. I felt like they viewed us all as some subhuman species that you don’t bother to acknowledge in public.

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Indiana Public Media News:

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

Search News

Stay Connected

RSS e-mail itunes Facebook Twitter Flickr YouTube

Follow us on Twitter

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Indiana Public Media News:

Recent Politics Stories

Recent Videos

Find Us on Facebook