What Are The Chances HJR-3 Would Pass In 2016?

Political analysts say the measure has less of a chance for approval in 2016 than it would have if it were on the ballot this year.

More than two decades ago, Bloomington resident Philip Cooper’s daughter left Indiana after graduating high school.

She’s been back for visits since then, but moving back for good? She told her father that it would be uncomfortable.

“Isn’t that sad?” Cooper says. “That the climate here makes anyone, in this case my daughter, uncomfortable to have to come back. That’s not the world we want to have for anyone.”

Cooper’s daughter is a lesbian and because of her, he’s made several trips to the statehouse in the last few weeks to join the protests against House Joint Resolution 3, the proposed constitutional amendment to define marriage as between a man and a woman.

Before the Senate heard the measure Thursday, Cooper said he was thinking about leaving the state if it was voted into the state constitution.

“I will choose not to live in an environment myself where every person I look at I have to think did you vote against my daughter or did you vote for her,” Cooper said with tears in his eyes. “I won’t do that.”

But Cooper won’t leave the state now – at least not this year.

Last month, the House amended the measure to remove the second sentence, which would have banned civil unions, and restart the ratification process.

The Senate on Thursday could have reinserted the second sentence but didn’t, meaning the amendment cannot go on the ballot this year.

But if the legislature passes the amendment either next year or the year after that, it would go on the 2016 ballot.

Changing Public Opinion, Voter Demographics Could Affect HJR-3

Indiana University political science professor Marjorie Hershey says a lot can happen in two years, but there are definite trends when it comes to same-sex marriage.

“One of things that has been most remarkable is there’s been a tremendously fast change in public opinion about same-sex marriage,” Hershey says. “Ten years ago there were no states that legalized same-sex marriage. Now it’s 17 plus another two that are in the process. This is really unusual. It suggests a change in public opinion that means the longer people wait for this constitutional amendment, the less likely public opinion will support it.”

The chances the amendment would pass in 2016 are also lower because of who’s likely to vote in that election.

“In a presidential election we find younger voters more likely to turn out and also a more diverse electorate in terms of race and ethnicity,” Hershey says. “That means that an amendment like this is going to do better in a midterm year than it is going to do in a presidential year.”

And a lot depends a lot on the groups campaigning for and against amending the state’s constitution.

Thursday was a victory for the bi-partisan coalition called Freedom Indiana, which spent months recruiting high-profile companies and universities and filling the statehouse with protestors every time the bill comes up for a vote.

Standing in the midst of a crowd of HJR-3 opponents after the Senate session, Sen. Minority Leader Tim Lanane praised Freedom Indiana’s efforts.

“A constitution is not about the past, it’s about the future, and a constitution is about how we accept all Hoosiers who have the right to a pursuit of happiness in this great state of ours,” he said.

But the fight isn’t over.

Just this past week, a group called Young Hoosiers for Marriage called a press conference for its launch at the statehouse, saying Freedom Indiana did not represent all young people in the state.

“The primary reason the government is in the marriage business, or why we have marriage laws, is because the government has an interest in protecting children and ensuring that, whenever possible, they can have both a mom and dad in their life,” said Young Hoosiers for Marriage member Sarah Hill.

The Young Hoosiers for Marriage and other HJR-3 supporters have said they are going to keep pushing for the amendment’s passage.

On the other side, Freedom Indiana has also vowed to keep fighting all the way to 2016.

Jashin Lin

Jashin Lin is a reporter/videographer for WFIU and WTIU news. She has previously worked as a videographer/web producer for MO.gov and as a reporter/videographer for the College of Engineering at the University of Missouri-Columbia. She studied multimedia journalism and information technology at the University of Missouri-Columbia. You can follow her on Twitter @jashinlin.

View all posts by this author »

  • lastcamp2

    “The primary reason the government is in the marriage business….”
    It may be of interest to those with open minds to learn that government got into the “marriage business” by requiring the issuance of licenses simply because of a need to have an official record of who was married and who was not. It was not for the purpose of “protecting children and seeing to it that they had a mom and a dad.” Those are notions that have arisen in the minds of persons who are intent on grafting their personal, often religious beliefs onto the rest of society.
    I cannot refrain from the suggestion made by Ms. Hill about “children having a mom and a dad in their life.” All children with living parents have a “mom and a dad in their life.” There is, perhaps, a question of the manner and degree to which those parents are involved, but that certainly does not depend on whether the parents have a marriage license.
    It is unfortunate that some people don’t understand that these inane and absurd comments actually diminish the quality of their arguments.

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Indiana Public Media News:

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

Search News

Stay Connected

RSS e-mail itunes Facebook Twitter Flickr YouTube

Follow us on Twitter

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Indiana Public Media News:

Recent Politics Stories

Recent Videos

Find Us on Facebook