Give Now

Harmonia Early Music

Bach With A Twist, Part 2

Two recordings of the Bach cello suites, each with a completely different approach: Pieter Wispelway and Sigiswald Kuijken perform.

The Cello Suites

Two recordings of the Bach cello suites, each present a completely different approach: Pieter Wispelway performs on a 2012 release from the EPR-Classics label, and Sigiswald Kuijken performs on a 2009 Accent Records release.

Bach’s cello suites are almost a rite of passage for cellists whether they play modern cellos or baroque ones. And recordings of the suites are plentiful too. Like the violin sonatas and partitas, a successful performance requires that the player understand the harmony both implied and written into the music. Harmonic motion gives strong hints of how to play the music in terms of phrasing, timing, and articulation. Of course, every performer who records these works offers a special stamp and distinctive interpretation of the pieces, and Kuijiken and Wispelway are no different.

Pieter Wispelway

Wispelway performs on this recording with his cello tuned at A=392, a low pitch that is often associated with French baroque music, and is a full tone lower than where modern orchestras perform. The precedent for this choice of low pitch for Bach’s cello suites is something we won’t delve into today, but the effect it has on the music, together with a close miking, lends Wispelway’s recording a dramatic and earthy sound, full of texture.

This recording is in fact Wispelway’s third recording of the cello suites, an indication that even after his first two recordings he still felt he had something new to say. In preparing this newest offering, Wispelway worked with John Butt and Laurence Dreyfus, and many of Wispelway’s resulting musical decisions are presented in the documentary accompanying this 2-disc set. And, Wispelway may not be finished yet: he made this 3rd recording to celebrate his 50th birthday, but also indicated that 6 recordings for 6 cello suites isn’t out of the question!

Sigiswald Kuijken

There are all sorts of interesting things about the recording by Sigiswald Kuijken. His performing pitch on the recording is A=415, but the pitch is less of a main issue in this recording.  Instead, listeners will be more interested in the very special instrument that Kuijken is playing–a violoncello da spalla, which literally translates as  “shoulder cello.”

The violoncello da spalla, though held more like a violin than a cello, is smaller than what we would think of as a normal sized cello, but larger than a somewhat standard viola  and held against the body with a leather strap. 

Any detailed discussion of the cello suites is bound to bring up more questions than answers! But its worth pointing out that Sigiswald Kuijken is primarily a violinist. This is important because it seems that one of the attractions of the violoncello da spalla is that it can be easily learned by violinists—that is, the lateral bow stroke is more violin-like than cello-like, and the left-hand fingering is also more similar to what a violinist would do than a cellist.

There is the possibility that Bach may have composed the suites using this shoulder cello, but what version of the cello Bach meant them to be performed on is a question up for much debate! What’s more, during Bach’s lifetime a standard cello construction was still developing, so that makes it hard to pinpoint Bach’s exact intentions for the instrument.

J.S. Bach: D.1: tr.1. Suite for solo cello No. 1 in G major, BWV 1007: Prelude; tr. 13. Suite for solo cello No. 3 in C major, BWV 1009: Prelude; tr. 17. Suite for solo cello No. 3 in C major, BWV 1009: Bourée 1 & 2
Sigiswald Kuijken — Cello Suites (Accent Records, 2009)
Buy from Amazon »
album cover

J.S. Bach: D. 1: tr. 1. Suite no.1 in G major BWV 1007: Prelude; tr. 10. Suite no.2 in D minor BWV 1008: Sarabande; tr. 18. Suite no.3 in C major BWV 1009: Gigue
Peter Wispelwey — Bach: 6 Suites for Cello Solo (EPA, 2012)
Buy from Amazon »
album cover

J. S. Bach: D. 1, tr, 1. 6 Suites (Sonatas) for Cello, BWV 1007-12, Suite No.1 in G Major, BWV 1007: Prelude
Mstislav Rostropovich — Bach: Cello Suites (EMI Classics, 1995)
Buy from Amazon »
album cover

And we mentioned this book:

History of Performing Pitch: The Story of "A"
Bruce Haynes
Buy from Amazon »
album cover

J.S. Bach: D.1: tr.1. Suite for solo cello No. 1 in G major, BWV 1007: Prelude; tr. 13. Suite for solo cello No. 3 in C major, BWV 1009: Prelude; tr. 17. Suite for solo cello No. 3 in C major, BWV 1009: Bourée 1 & 2
Sigiswald Kuijken — Cello Suites (Accent Records, 2009)
Buy from Amazon »
album cover
J.S. Bach: D. 1: tr. 1. Suite no.1 in G major BWV 1007: Prelude; tr. 10. Suite no.2 in D minor BWV 1008: Sarabande; tr. 18. Suite no.3 in C major BWV 1009: Gigue
Peter Wispelwey — Bach: 6 Suites for Cello Solo (EPA, 2012)
Buy from Amazon »
album cover
J. S. Bach: D. 1, tr, 1. 6 Suites (Sonatas) for Cello, BWV 1007-12, Suite No.1 in G Major, BWV 1007: Prelude
Mstislav Rostropovich — Bach: Cello Suites (EMI Classics, 1995)
Buy from Amazon »
album cover
History of Performing Pitch: The Story of "A"
Bruce Haynes
Buy from Amazon »
album cover
Janelle Davis

Janelle Davis is a violinist and performer with period instrument ensembles throughout the United States. She is currently a candidate for the Doctor of Music degree from Indiana University, Bloomington where she specializes in early music.

View all posts by this author »

Stay Connected

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Harmonia Early Music:

More Subscription Options

Follow Us

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

About Harmonia Early Music

About The Hosts

Search Harmonia Early Music

where to hear harmonia