Give Now

Earth Eats: Real Food, Green Living

Farm Subsidy Program Could Get A Make-Over

President Obama outlined a plan to limit farm subsidies so that farmers who make over $250,000 will not receive them, but the plan met resistance.

farm

Photo: Pete Zarria (via Flickr)

How much should the government support large farms?

Trimming Wasteful Spending

During President Obama’s speech about the economy in his recent televised town hall meeting, he confronted farm subsidies. Under his proposed plan, farmers who make more than $250,000 in annual income will not be able to receive federally supported farm substitutes.

The President says that limiting who can receive farm subsidies will protect small farmers while not wasting government money by giving it to large agribusiness farmers who don’t need it.

“Part of what we want to do is to make sure that help is going to family farms in crisis situations. Drought, disaster and so forth,” said Mr. Obama, “that we’re not just giving ongoing subsidies to big agribusiness, which is the way that a lot of our farm programs work right now.”

This change could save the government $9.7 billion over a period of ten years.

A History of Resistance

Obama’s plan has met resistance from many areas of the political spectrum.

Farm lobbyists like the National Farmer’s Union fiercely oppose the measure. They argue that limiting who gets farm subsidies will not save the government as much money as it anticipates (hundreds of millions of dollars instead of the billions that are predicted), and will hurt medium-size farms more than corporate agribusiness.

Other presidents – including President George W Bush in 2007 – have tried to cut farm subsidies before, but also to no avail.

Farm subsidies are backed by a powerful combination of history and bipartisan support. Congressmen are quick to defend their state’s agricultural interests regardless of their political affiliation, and the farm subsidies have been part of the nation’s agricultural political framework since the Jeffersonian Agricultural Ideal.

Even some organizations that have pushed for ending farm subsidies say that the timing and presentation of President Obama’s proposal hurt its chances of success. Ken Cook from the Environmental Working Group, a nonprofit that has fought against farm subsidies, said that it may have alienated those who supported Obama’s reform agenda. Cook says that the president’s administration should have strengthened innovations in climate change and healthcare instead of attacking the farm subsidy system.

Keeping In Touch

Administration officials argue that Obama’s plan to reduce farm subsidies is in line with his other goals, because even though this proposal was defeated by the Budget Committees, the same Budget Committees adopted resolutions to protect health care, energy, and education spending.

The Obama administration intends to continue conversation about reducing the federal deficit by limiting farm subsidies to find the best way to “support rural America and get some savings and efficiencies out of agricultural programs.”

Read More:

  • Obama calls for “revamping” of farm support system, possible income caps for subsidies (CBS News)
  • Obama’s Farm Subsidy Cuts Meet Stiff Resistance (The New York Times)
Julie Rooney

Julie Rooney is a vegetarian, musician, and artist who primarily works in video and new media. Currently she is the director of Low Road Gallery, a non-profit contemporary art gallery located in Greencastle, Indiana.

View all posts by this author »

  • Kefishbu

    On the face of this, it sounds good. My concern would be for the middle farmers falling through the cracks like middle anyone.  Protecting and helping the struggling small farmers is great!  Local small farm agriculture is good for our health and local economies. Big agribusiness definitely should not, in any way,  be subsidized by our tax dollars.  Hopefully there will be protocol for timely review of those in the middle so their farms don’t suffer.
    It seems a major impediment to passing would be the marriage of big agribusiness and it’s governing bodies.  And then there is the big money to campaigns from big ag.  That is a huge obstacle and it will take a great deal of courage on the part of elected officials to ignore the power of big ag, and do what’s right.  
    Good luck.

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Earth Eats:

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

About Earth Eats

Search Earth Eats

Earth Eats on Twitter

Earth Eats on Flickr

Harvest Public Media