Give Now

Earth Eats: Real Food, Green Living

After Food, Inc.: Will Anything Really Change?

With the Internet buzzing about Food, Inc., Cory Barker wonders what (if anything) will come of its release.

mcdonalds sign and a small farm

Photo: Dog Company and Roadside Pictures (Flickr)

With the Internet buzzing about Food, Inc., Cory Barker wonders what (if anything) will come of its release.

McDonalds and a Local Farm

Food, Inc. has many in the blogosphere all up in arms due to its sobering look at how factory farms truly operate. We’re sad that the Robert Kenner-directed, Eric Schlosser-produced documentaryhas yet to reach Indiana viewers, but the lessons from the film remain on our minds.

After reading the tremendous review of the film that Patricia Eddy wrote for us, I too was riled up about the deceptive tactics used by major factory farming operations.

However, something else, perhaps the cynical side of me kept creeping in – will this film actually change anything?

Sure, I can imagine watching the film will change the minds of individuals, perhaps even a whole lot of them. But will that truly improve anything? Let me be clear, I am not saying Food, Inc. is pointless or it won’t do its part to help break the “big food” stranglehold, I am just curious as to how much change is really possible, how it will happen and who will be involved.

It’s On Us, Can You Handle That?

Not surprisingly, the movement that may form in reaction to this film will be a collection of many individuals’ actions. In her review’s closing thoughts, Patricia Eddy says:

The most important takeaway that I have from the movie is that we need to vote with our shopping habits. Do you want to eliminate CAFO meat from your life? How about eliminating CAFO meat from the United States? Then don’t buy that CAFO meat from the grocery store. Shop the farmers markets, buy organic when you can, local whenever possible. Know what foods are in season. Don’t buy peaches in February. Read labels. Know what is in your food.

I don’t think Eddy is naive enough to suggest that a few individuals acting alone can help solve the problems presented in the film, but I wonder: can we really even put a dent in them?

At this point, post-release of Food, Inc. people who care passionately about these issues are energized by the film’s message and what they hope to accomplish in their grassroots battles against CAFOs, or whomever else.

But CAFOs are powerful, so, will any movements last much beyond the swirl surrounding the film’s release, especially when so many people are starving, losing their jobs or busy dealing with their own personal tragedies?

Change? Maybe.

To attempt to sketch out one possible answer to this question, why don’t we look to the response to another major food-related documentary released earlier this decade – Super Size Me.

After Morgan Spurlock’s 30-day diet of nothing but McDonald’s menu items and the release of the subsequent documentary, McDonalds did, in fact, phase out Super Size menu items. It was also around that time that the fast food giant began offering supposedly more “healthy” alternatives in the form of grilled chicken, salad, fruit, etc., but even those aren’t as healthy as they seem.

In the last five years, however, McDonald’s market share in the fast food industry has actually increased to 46.8% while it has been quick to release new products into the marketplace that have quickly become popular, like the McCafe coffee line.

So, aside from some lawsuits here and there, which McDonald’s was surely dealing with before the film hit theaters, and a more general disdain for their products and practices by the socially-aware, McDonald’s is still chugging along as a worldwide power.

Even Schlosser’s book Fast Food Nation and film adaptation of that material failed to really mobilize a greater movement against the golden arches.

Is it because people just love the food at McDonald’s? Partially. Is it because they didn’t have all the cool social networking devices like Twitter or Facebook at their disposal to spread the anti-McDonald’s gospel? Maybe just a little.

In reality, sad as it is to say, the lack of progress made against McDonald’s and fast food in general is likely due to both the apathy of most people and the sheer size of the corporations and sectors they’d have to rise up against.

People act in their own self interest, and even if they know that we are a fat nation. If it does not seem to directly affect them, and they still get to eat Double Cheeseburgers at reasonable prices, they’re still pro-McDonald’s.

Does their self interest also apply to Factory Farming?

Be Optimistic, But Not Unrealistic

I think so.

I imagine that for the rest of the summer, the general public will become more and more enthralled with the movement to fight The Powers That Be portrayed in Food, Inc. But, by the time fall rolls around, they’ll forget that for the most part unless it comes up in water cooler-like discussions.

The diehard environmentally conscious, anti-factory farming camp are certainly not going to let this go away. They’ll tweet about it, they’ll start Facebook groups and craft posts more optimistic than this one.

And I hope that they actually get a movement started that does change some things, if even a little. But even the most optimistic person has to recognize the forces we’re up against here. It’s a sad reality, and even worse that an underground movement probably can’t fix everything.

But they can try.

What do you think?

Will Food, Inc. change how we look at food and farming? Leave a comment and tell us what you think the movie’s lasting impact will be.

Cory Barker

Cory Barker is a summer intern for Earth Eats and senior IU student from Hartford City, Indiana. He is double majoring in journalism and communication and culture with a minor in business.

View all posts by this author »

  • Patricia Eddy

    Do I think that one person can change the world? Well, no, probably not in this case. However, one person telling another person telling another person and maybe we’ve got something going here.

    I certainly understand your perspective. You are correct that we are up against a huge brick wall that is CAFO meat and Monsanto. However encouraging people to see Food, Inc., encouraging people to read about the issues is the best thing we can do. Will it work overnight? Of course not. However three years ago there was one grass fed beef vendor at my local farmers market and they never ran out of product. Now there are five and by the end of the day, they sometimes sell out.

    Three years ago no restaurant my area bragged about their meat being humanely treated or grass fed. Now a lot of them do. Is this enough? Absolutely not. But it is a start.

    Whether you are optimistic or pessimistic about the future, however, definitely keep talking about the issues. Thanks for a great read, Cory.

  • http://??? educate yourself

    There can be no equality or opportunity if men and women and children be not shielded in their lives from the consequences of great industrial and social processes which they cannot alter, control, or singly cope with.
    Woodrow Wilson

    Not necessarily just a job for the masses but as duly elected representatives for the PEOPLE governments need to tell these corporations must adhere to the law or be disbanded….it will only take one country brave to start this and maybe suffer the initial financial downturn for many others to follow and bring the power back to where it belongs….with the everyman as opposed to the man with the dollar signs in his eyes….money cant save you when all food is poisoned.

  • Pingback: Food, Inc. On PBS April 21st, Host Your Own Food, Inc. Potluck! | Earth Eats - Indiana Public Media

What is RSS? RSS makes it possible to subscribe to a website's updates instead of visiting it by delivering new posts to your RSS reader automatically. Choose to receive some or all of the updates from Earth Eats:

Support For Indiana Public Media Comes From

About Earth Eats

Search Earth Eats

Earth Eats on Twitter

Earth Eats on Flickr

Harvest Public Media